News Update:
Something is definitely amiss when police in Spain and Portugal are coming together to take a closer look at the case of seven year old Jeremy Vargas, who went missing from outside his home in Gran Canaria, Spain eight weeks before Madeleine McCann according to this report here, here and here. The search has reached the stage where they are diving for Maddie’s body in a reservoir here, here, here and here as Portugal’s top cop admits that they blundered in their hasty accusations of the McCanns here and here. Parents going to foreign lands on holiday with young children in tow should beware as the torment of losing a child to only God knows what horrors will never be worth that one relaxing dinner with friends.
Please watch this really eye-opening Australian videoclip (source here) on how easy it is for children to expose themselves to the danger of abduction by strangers. Despite being taught not to open doors when home alone or leave the car to help a stranger, they still do it anyway and it does not take much to coax them into it. Imagine the danger they face walking to and from school or at the playground? I shudder at the thought! I hope police are following up leads on attempted child abductions that may have happened recently, in the run up to both Nini’s and Nurin’s abductions. The Police should also start issuing warnings to the public about stranger dangers and to begin public awareness messages aimed at parents, teachers and schoolchildren on how to avoid being victims. Failure to be on the alert may mean another Nurin or Nini and that is certainly not what we want!
In my frustration while awaiting good news about Nini, I continue surfing for more information and I find that the world has become a strange and terrifying place with more and more news reports of missing children. But I get the feeling there is more to these foiled abductions than meets the eye. Since Nurin and Nini, I have been wary that maybe many of such reports are not taken seriously enough by both the public and police. Have there been many in the run up to both Nurin’s and Nini’s abductions and in which areas or parts of the city? Aside from the child victims of the ‘lelaki kucing”, how many more near misses are we looking at I wonder? A new commentor, Rita Ho, who lives in the US with her husband David, writes on her blog “I’m Making Notes” ( http://ritaho.blogspot.com ) about her own near miss, Rita writes:
Children are taught to be kind & helpful to others but distrustful & careful of strangers at the same time. It is a difficult concept for kids to grasp. Even adults don’t always make that distinction easily. We fall victims to deception all the time as I almost did some 5 years ago. The circumstances weren’t drastic but the realization of what could have happened remains stuck in my mind…..
There is even a report here in the Malay Mail from a parent who wrote
Narrow escape for children
Dear Editor,ON Jan 29, my mother took my two sons, aged five and one, to a sundry shop in Taman Shamelin to buy news papers. My mother decided to walk as the shop is nearby. During their journey, they had to pass five houses. While walking with my children, she could hear the sound of a motorcycle coming up behind them. When the motorcycle approached them, my mother saw the motorcyclist and a woman sitting behind him. My mother described him as a thin man and the woman had fair skin. He stopped in front of them and asked her: “Ada kerja? (Got any thing to do?).” My mother shook her head indicating that she did not want to have anything to do with him. To her horror, the man took a piece of wood and stepped down from his motorcycle. He moved nearer and aimed the wooden plank at my mother’s head. He pointed to my sons and shouted “Kasi! Kasi! (Give! Give!).” The man wanted to abduct my sons. Instinctively, my mother shouted “Jangan! Jangan! (No! No!)” and tried to shield her grandsons from the blow. The kidnapper’s accomplice sat on the motorcycle waiting for the kidnapper’s orders. Out of desperation, my mother ran to nearby houses screaming for help. Her action frightened the would-be kidnapper and the couple took off on the motor cycle. After my mother related the incident to me, we immediately lodged a report at the Pandan Indah police station. I am grateful my sons had made a narrow escape. I hope this letter will shed some light on the likelihood of abduction. Parents should take precautions for the safety of their children. Through this incident, I can relate to the recent abduction cases.I hope society will learn from this and do its best to protect children from kidnappers. I thank God for protecting my sons.
Amarjit Singh
Taman Cheras Indah
What I am glad to note is that both Rita and Amarjit did lodge a police report. Would Malaysian police accept these kinds of reports or do they discourage them as the child was not taken. I do hope the IGP will instruct all police officers to take reports of attempted abduction just as seriously as any child abduction. There could be an answer in such abduction attempts that might connect the dots in this increasingly dim chance of finding Nini. Although I am temporarily assured by Bernama’s report “Sharlinie Still Alive And In Malaysia – Police“, I still wonder if the police are just guessing?
“We have not received any report or evidence of her body being found anywhere… so we take it that she’s still alive,” Petaling Jaya district police chief ACP Arjunaidi Mohamad told reporters here today. He said police also believed that the missing girl was still in the country as it had not received any information from Interpol to indicate otherwise. “We believe that Sharlinie’s abductor is being extra careful now with regards to his movements or actions as he is aware of the massive operation being mounted to find the girl.” He said based on this premise, police would continue searching for Sharlinie with a number of strategies planned. “We will not reveal the strategies to the public nor the media. If we talk about them everyday, it will interfere with our investigations and give more opportunities for the abductor to escape the dragnet,” he added.”
But I am concerned with another recent Bernama report here:
Police have no plans yet to engage any foreign intelligence help to find five-year-old Sharlinie Mohd Nashar who has been missing since Jan 9. Selangor police chief DCP Datuk Khalid Abu Bakar said it was still too early to do so as the operations to find the missing girl also involved Malaysian Interpol. “We have a credible Interpol team and there are no plans to enlist the services of any foreign intelligence agency in the immediate future. “The Interpol service is sufficient. Maybe police will use the services of another intelligence agency if really necessary,” he said after opening a crime-prevention campaign at the Seri Kembangan multipurpose hall, near here, today. Khalid said in the absence of new information on the case, police were unable to do any specific follow-up….
PS – I also would like to thank blogger Wahdi who originally came up with the photofits of Sharlinie in his blog ( www.wahdi.blogspot.com ) and blogger AnnKanni ( http://blog.annkanni.com/ ) for alerting me about it. I am so grateful that blogosphere is populated with great bloggers who are equally great people like you guys. Cheers!
I think Mr. Amarjit Singh might have encountered possible child traffickers. I found an article the other day relating to child trafficking in SEA, but I didn’t save it – my laptop chose that very moment to crash. This is highly disturbing if they can be this bold.
An attempted snatch with an adult present. Are we still on with the whole parental negligence charge, people?
I meant, Mr. Amarjit Singh’s mother, of course.
I found thse videos on YouTube but just didn’t have the heart to post them. Warning, please do not watch these videos if you are faint hearted because it features the stories of some very young children in India, Philippines from poor families trying to survive that will break your heart.
Munira, you might want to watch these to learn more about the global problem of trafficking children into the sex trade that is both horrifying and all too real. The trend is rising worldwide and I do hope all parents and the authorities are on the alert. We have to stem the tide.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=goLwNgRx1A8
http://youtube.com/watch?v=UcHoGNs03Lg
http://youtube.com/watch?v=NWQ9ZaxjFys
My God… the ugly secrets the genial SEA culture buries behind closed doors…
I’ve read up child trafficking before, but not truly in-depth. Thank you for the links to these vids.
I wonder what’s our authorities’ take on this? I remember that sometime last year we were blacklisted for human trafficking, but there was an uproar about it, denying the allegations. Is that right? I didn’t really follow it, so I need someone to clarify the issue – did we deserve the negative acknowledgement or not?
Thinking about that poor little boy’s fate a decade ago… the one who was snatched from his school compound on his very first day in school. That was so tragic.
And heinous.
Kak T, have you seen this? It’s related to both abduction and exploitation:
Protective Environment: What can you do?
Munira, child abductions is just the tip of the iceberg in child trafficking but I believe Malaysians have never felt that the issue was as close to home as it is now. We always felt so smugly secure that these things happen to children in other countries. After all we are not that poor and we are a Muslim country. I think our carelessness and preoccupation with making money, we overlooked many of these dangers. The abduction of Nini and Nurin are just symptoms of what ails society in general, our apathy and lack of practical and common sense approaches in dealing with these types of problems.
Naturally the authorities in all these countries, including Malaysia, will never openly acknowledge problems such as sex tourism, paedophilia and human trafficking even exist. Psychologically I don’t want to believe it either but there are bodies and NGOS who are working very hard to address these problems. Thing is, we mix up so many issues that we never really focus on the solutions. Child abduction is one issue we need to address while the NURIN Alert is trying to address the issue of a system of procedures that will increase the chances of finding abducted children alive.
The issue of child abuse, rape, runaways, child trafficking and internet predators and all those perplexing issues need to be addressed just as seriously but separately. If we try to do too many things at once, it will result in doing all things poorly. What Malaysia has on paper is some resolutions, meetings, reports and forums. Whether these translates into real action I have no idea. Chances are that many of these trafficked children barely make it out alive. In Malaysia, many trafficked women end up deported for immigration offences such as overstaying etc. But I really don’t know about the involvement of children and whether there are syndicates involved in abducting them for purposes other than the more usual begging.
Chances are we assumed those children brought here to beg are children of the beggars themselves. Could it be they are children abducted in some foreign lands who are now classified as missing children? Are they also forced to do unimaginable things other then begging. It is too painful to even think about it but once plucked from the protection of their families, there is nothing to protect defenceless children from a life of horror. I pray Nini is spared from such a fate and hope the authorities will take a more serious view of attempted abductions and begin sending some serious messages about prevention. We all have to work together on this.
Check these sites out:
http://brighton.amnesty.org.uk/uploads/documents/doc_17119.pdf
http://www.humantrafficking.org/organizations/174
http://www.unicef.org/malaysia/media_4956.html
http://www.aegis.com/news/ips/2005/IP050202.html
http://www.asiapacificforum.net/about/annual-meetings/8th-nepal-2004/downloads/report-from-apf-members-on-acj-standing-issues/malaysia_acj.pdf
http://www.cwcc.org.kh/downloads/TRAFFICKING%20OF%20CAMBODIAN%20WOMEN%20AND%20CHILDREN.pdf
http://www.wccpenang.org/wcc/images/legaldocs/article_6.pdf
http://www.asiapacificforum.net/services/training/regional-workshops/trafficking/downloads/session-2/s2-pillai.pdf
Helo Kak,
“Selangor police chief DCP Datuk Khalid Abu Bakar said it was still too early to do so as the operations to find the missing girl also involved Malaysian Interpol. “We have a credible Interpol team and there are no plans to enlist the services of any foreign intelligence agency in the immediate future. “The Interpol service is sufficient. Maybe police will use the services of another intelligence agency if really necessary,”
Wow…missing since Jan 9 still consider ’still early’..wonder when does it become ‘late’ or ‘urgent’.
Sometimes comments made by these people really kinda make ur day.
Nightwing, from the responses our police officers make to the media, I realise they are not well trained in public relations and crisis communications. Whoever the PR consultants they have hired had better give them some pointers on what they should and should not say to the media that would not hamper investigations and pre-empt any operations they are planning.
I noticed that this time around ACP Arjunaidi is making a real effort to keep the public informed on progress of the search. However, as the search seems to drag with no new leads, the police have to engage the public on other possible angles such as reports of attempted abductions. Reminders to public on child safety. I am afraid from the IGP and down, they need to review their communication skills to the public. I’d be happy if they keep everything under wraps in covert operations and by a miracle produce the child, found safe and sound. But in these kinds of cases, the public should not be left in the dark as there is always a possibility the perpetrators are going to get some other child.
Every report of attempted abduction should be taken seriously. There should be public awareness campaigns by the police through the media and through their Rakancop programmes for schoolchildren, parents and teachers. This is a new trend we are dealing with here and it is better to be safe than to live in regret!
We are only human and we are learning together Nightwing.
Hi tembam, not a day goes by without thinking of Ninie, she just wont let me, her pictures are everywhere and I feel her in my heart. Again, why are we not on a full or red alert, the Gov need to warn everyone on such kidnappings, put it on front page so that everyone takes full preventive precaution. Luckily Amarjit’s family was just – LUCKY, cant say for the next potential victim. Here I am a lunatic mom nagging my kids about safety day & night, sometimes changing my schedule so they dont have to wait so long for their regular transporter after school. So, we are not just talking about a few crazy men, could be a couple working hand in hand, not just kidnapping for sexual reasons but also into child traficking, selling them overseas for all the wrong and sickening reasons. As for the police’s statement on ‘credible interpol team here’, hmm…faham2 saja la, and to conclude that the child is still alive because there is no body found? If they are Nurin’s killer, they may not want to act the same again, afteralll they had a narrow escape after being captured on CCTV. Again, it’s been a frustrating 3 weeks and coming to 1 month for all of us. what can i do except pray for this poor child? please whoever it is, return this child back to her family
Me too, Mary Kate! Just trying to make some sense out of it through this blog. Been hoping with all the attention we would have found her by now. Since we haven’t just don’t know what else to do. Better go on prevention mode full swing in the hopes that it won’t happen to another child. It’s too easy for the perps. We shouldn’t allow our kids to be another statistic. Take good care of them and adjust your lifestyle so that they come first. Many parents don’t put priority on their children’s safety. Just look at this from blogger Arip
http://enarip.blogspot.com/2008/02/post-natal-family-planning-for-dummies.html
Imagine your paranoia and the oblivious parents of that little girl. I’d rather be paranoid!
yep, tembam, saw enarip’s blog. It shows about malaysians attitude, that and “it wont happen to me or my child” syndrom, very dangereous. again, not safe times for all children now, and fully agree on the prevention thing – it’s the best thing a parent can give their children, preventing such kidnappings and keeping them safe. tks a million for keeping all of us updated.
Mary Kate, you must be busy cleaning, baking and decorating the house. Let’s pray the new year bring good fortune and prospertiy and maybe Nini’s homecoming. InsyaAllah!
Check out this report on Harian Metro where Kamal Afandi Hashim is giving some good tips on how kids can escape from the abductor. Good idea to send kids to those self-defense classes. Maybe they will be brave enough and have an idea how to release themselves from the perpetrator’s clutches. We have to get our kids away from being a target as potential victims. They need to take control of their own safety, within their capability of course!
http://www.hmetro.com.my/Current_News/myMetro/Saturday/Hati/20080202112802/Article/index_html
Self-defense lessons are very important. I’ve been learning since I was a kid, taekwondo, kung-fu… and now jujitsu in university here. Plus it helps build character, I do believe.
One other useful method of child safety is teaching your kids a safeword (password) that only you and your children should share between yourselves. I think it’s a common practice in the US. Safewords are useful in case some strangers hustle up to your child at school or something, pretending to be a family friend sent to pick him up. If your child is alert and taught well, then he should ask this person if he really was sent by the parents, and ask for the safeword.
Obviously if this stranger is an abductor in the making, he’d have no clue what the safeword is!
It is also mentioned here:
Yes, it should be encouraged. Unfortunately very few schools have such clubs. I know my son joined one Taekwando class orgaised under Rakan Muda when he was in primary school but because it was held on weekends or after school hours we could not keep up and he finally dropped out. Later he took up Aikido before going to college but couldn’t continue as the college didn’t have a club. Same thing with my daughter who was mad about fencing. I got her into a small club run by a couple of fencing enthusiasts, however she stopped because of SPM. She then tried to revive he passion by joining another fencing club but by then she was in college and just did not have the time. I wish they had more of these types of self-defense classes and not just Silat.
However, I used to joke with my daughter the only snag about her passion for fencing was that when attacked, you’d have to say “Hold on, let me get my sword!”. Really gets her mad when I say that!
hey…tembam, like the one about your daughter holding on and getting the sword hehehehe. was out yesterday and my kids kept asking about Ninie and where she is and when she can come home, I can only say that nobody knows for sure and we really need a miracle for this to happen and that we continue hoping and praying. What else? anyway, am off 2morow and back next week, so take care good friend and until we meet or blog again
Hehehe….if she knows I blogged about it she will get even more mad. My daughter is in argumentative mode right now, asserting her right to freedom of speech in her own way! Sigh, I remember when a hug and kiss from mommy was good enough!!!
You have a good holiday Mary Kate. Enjoy the time with your family, after this our real year begins and no more play, play!
tembam, i copied tht letter fr mr amarjit and email them to my family and friends in msia esp since tht place is so close to my parent’s!
they are so bold and the fact tht the kids were w their grandmother didn even scare/deter them fr trying to abduct is raelly scary. makes me thinking if Msia is now being targeted for international child traficking ring?
Farina exactly my unspoken fears. I gather that the complacency we seem to display with children is encouraging such possibilities? No more time for such carelessness, not until the police prove otherwise. Whatever it is, we really need to be vigilant at all times. It’s too scary to see the way Malaysians are with children in public places let alone at home where their kids roam free unsupervised.